Just depends how bad someone needs it and how close they are located near you so travel shipping don't bite into it. If I needed one right away and you were within a hour away I would pay $400.00 or more as the yards around here want $350.00 for any rear and it will need gone over. I understand what your saying very well its like my NOS bedside the most I was offered was $100.00 with it needing shipped. A cheap china fender is around $75.00 bucks I would cut it up and scrap it or cut patches out of for mine first.