I've been a Jeep guy my whole life, owned 3 XJ's, first car was an 84 Cherokee, started a restore on a 89 Wagoneer, it was stolen, and pretty much finished a good 79 Wagoneer I just sold. My current daily driver is a 79 CJ7 with a 258 that my father bought new.
I decided I wanted a Comanche about 6 months ago. I started looking really hard about 3-4 months ago. I'm being really picky, I want a color I like, if I can original paint with the original stripping down the sides, all stock, 6.0 inline six, 5 speed, 4wd, bench seat with headrests.
I'm in Atlanta, GA and have alerts setup for anything within about a 6 hour drive on Craigslist and search forums as well.
Not much luck.
About a month ago I saw a good stock Comanche, 6 cylinder, 5 speed, only 2wd, new red paint job (not a color I like), with 89k original miles sell in about a day in AL for 6k. I called on a Wednesday, wasn't exactly what I wanted, but close, planned to go see it that Saturday, sold next day before I could get to see it.
I saw another one in South Caroline about a month ago, 6 cylinder, automatic, 4wd, original paint, about 70k original miles, sold for 6,300 in a day, didn't make it there in time either.
Most others are modified, terrible shape, have the 4 cylinder engine, have the old 2.8 V6, have terrible bodies with rust and rot, don't run, and just in terrible shape all around.
Struggling.
I then decided to stop caring about the color or the seats, but still engine, 5 speed, and 4wd.
I found one today, all original, owner was looking for trade but willing to sell, but wanted 7k, firm!
It is pretty much exactly what I was looking for!
He said he had turned down 6,500 today!
It has 196k original miles, that's a lot!
I have the specs below, but he also said he had engine rebuilt, but with further discussion I learned when replacing rear main seal that was leaking, he just did the main bearings, oil pump, and rod bearings, not a rebuilt engine really. He said the compression was all 135 on all cylinders, so makes sense to not bore it out, but maybe do the top end? He also says no rust at all anywhere on the car, it was kept in a garage. He says some clear coat missing, but no rust.
He drives it regularly and says it runs flawlessly.
I'm not really worried about mileage, but the price should be closer to 5k-6k I would think, but he's not interested in taking less.
It's 3 hours away, he claims people coming for trade on Friday and Saturday.
Is this thing worth it? Have good stock original Comanches with no rust become this hard to find? I feel after 3 months I will never find another one. This is actually the first, stock, good running, good paint, no rust, 6 cylinder, 5 speed, 4wd Comanche I have seen come up since I started searching.
196k original miles
new clutch plate/pressure plate
new clutch master cylinder and slave cylinder
new rotors
new brakes
new calipers
new wheel cylinders
all gauges work and shows over 60 psi
A/C works
new muffler
new rear main seal
new rod bearings
new main bearings
new oil pump