Ok, new info....
I counted the splines on my transmission, and it has 10 and 21. I also looked up the serial number, and it looks like I was sold a Peugeot and not an Aisin (53005252).
This being the case, should I just swap in the Peugeot? I was going to swap everything (bellhousing, mounts, transfer case, etc), but if I already have the transmission it would save me money and time to just throw it in... on the other hand, I know the Peugeots weren't the best transmissions. Will I regret not going with the ax-15?