I bought a new FEY bumper about a year ago and it was a identical match to the stock bumper. I even used the original mounting brackets even though I bought the mounting kit. The OEM bumper was just basic black.
This is what I found
http://westinautomotive.com/westin/viewproduct.jsp?prod=FEY+Diamond+Step+Bumpers&id=37&vehicleId=&year=1990&make=JEEP&model=Comanche&submodel=&cabstyle=&guid=3e527018-3278-86b9-692b-ebdb384df1f0
Shop around and you will likely find a better deal, I think I paid just over $100.