Just talked to the wife of the seller...
204K miles (OUCH), Orig 4.0L (orig Tranny, not sure which), AC, Newer tires, no Major Dings/Rush, etc.
KBB Top ends out no more than $1800, even in EXCELLENT condition with those miles and the basic options selected.
Excellent $1,760
Good $1,530
Fair $1,135
Worth a drive down the way (about an hour south of me), but I don't think I would be willing to go much more than $1500 and that might insult the guy asking $2500.
SW2