Well I took the tstat out today and took it up on the hill after topping off the coolant. Everything seemed fine, the temp went a little over 210 but not very far.
I then took it down to my parents hay field and ran it pretty hard doing some donuts and stuff, purposely trying to raise the temp. Well, it worked and the gauge spiked to 250. I immediately stopped and shut the engine off. I let it sit for about 15 minutes and turned the key to on. Oddly enough, the gauge spiked back to 250. So I started it up and it almost immediately dropped back down to 210.
I went back to the house and let it sit and run and it started creeping back up to 250. I let it keep running to see if there was any coolant being spit out. There wasn't a drop coming out. If that thing was really that hot shouldn't it be spitting coolant? Also one time my buddy's cherokee got hot bc of a stuck thermostat and it started knocking and sounded awful. My motor doesn't make a weird noise at all.
What I am getting at is, could it be possible that the gauge is more at fault here than actual heat? These are aftermarket auto meter gauges and the oil pressure and fuel gauges also act weird.